Where to Find the Best Holiday Pies and Baked Goods Around Madison

Holiday memories are that much sweeter when shared with a great meal and an even better dessert. Local bakeries around the Madison area are serving up all of your holiday favorites, with desserts to complement any meal. Settle in for a deep dive on where to order delicious desserts around Madison this holiday season.

Where to Order Holiday Desserts Around Madison

At a Glance: Six Local Bakeries to Explore

• Hubbard Avenue Diner – Middleton: Seasonal pies, classic favorites and take-n-bake options.
• Batch Bakehouse – Madison: Custom cakes, holiday specialties and freshly baked treats.
• Rolling Pin Bake Shop – Fitchburg: Russian, European and American desserts, plus holiday orders.
• Clasen's European Bakery – Middleton: European cakes, tortes, cookies and chocolate specialties.
• Bloom Bake Shop – Madison: Fresh breads, sweet potato doughnuts and made-from-scratch pastries.
• Fosdal Home Bakery – Stoughton: Traditional baked goods, custom cakes and Norwegian holiday favorites.

Hubbard Avenue Diner – Middleton, WI

Address: 7445 Hubbard Ave., Middleton, WI 53562

Hubbard Avenue Diner offers a new selection of featured pies monthly, along with a variety of classics that are always available. You can easily pre-order pies through their website, then pick them up the next day at their convenient location near Middleton homes for sale. They also offer take-n-bake treats, ready to be baked fresh in your oven at home.

Batch Bakehouse – Madison, WI

Address: 1402 Williamson St., Madison, WI 53703

Batch Bakehouse is a locally-owned bakery near Madison homes for sale, with special menus for holiday occasions and a diverse selection of sweet treats. You can order a custom cake online (three days' notice required) or stop by the shop to see what's fresh each day. Since the menu is updated regularly, certain items are only available if you visit the shop in person.

Rolling Pin Bake Shop – Fitchburg, WI

Address: 2935 S. Fish Hatchery Road, Fitchburg, WI 53711

The team at Rolling Pin Bake Shop is already taking holiday orders, making it easy to plan ahead for your holiday desserts. You can stop by their shop around the corner from Fitchburg homes for sale to create custom orders for the holidays, or visit closer to your event to see what's available fresh that day. They offer a mix of Russian, European and American desserts, so there's always something new to try here.

Clasen's European Bakery – Middleton, WI

Address: 7610 Donna Drive, Middleton, WI 53562

Clasen's European Bakery brings the flavors of Europe to Wisconsin, created with classic, time-tested recipes and featuring items you won't find at most bakeries. From their signature Dark Chocolate Hazelnut EuroBark to cookies, cakes, tortes, pies and more, this shop has it all. They even offer nationwide shipping on select items for all of your gifting needs, or if you're craving a taste of Wisconsin while away from home for the holidays.

Bloom Bake Shop – Madison, WI

Addresses: 1851 Monroe St., Madison, WI 53711; 557 North St., Madison, WI 53704

Fresh bread can be just as welcome as dessert at a holiday gathering, and Bloom Bake Shop offers plenty of both. Fresh bread is available after 10 a.m. daily at their Monroe Street location, with a smaller selection of bread available at their North Street store. They also offer a great selection of fresh, made-from-scratch sweets, including their very popular sweet potato doughnuts.

Fosdal Home Bakery – Stoughton, WI

Address: 243 E. Main St., Stoughton, WI 53589

An award-winning, old-fashioned bakery with a reputation for friendly service, Fosdal Home Bakery has you covered for holiday orders large and small near Stoughton homes for sale. Their custom cakes are perfect for large holiday gatherings, and they also have all your other bakery favorites. They offer some unique Norwegian sweets during the holidays, along with a great selection of coffee and tea to serve with your desserts.

Serve Something Sweet in Your Madison Home This Holiday Season

Searching for a home around Madison where you can create holiday memories with your family? Our local team is here to help you achieve your real estate goals. Contact us to buy and sell homes throughout the Madison, WI area.